worst shingles

The Worst Shingles of 2023: Avoid These Brands for Your Roof

Are you planning to invest in a new roof for your home?

The quality of the shingles you choose can make all the difference between a long-lasting, high-performance roof and a series of costly repairs.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the importance of selecting quality shingles, how to identify low-quality brands, and common problems associated with poor-quality shingles.

We will also provide you with a list of the worst shingles manufacturers to avoid in 2023 and tips on how to protect your roof from the negative effects of low-quality shingles.

Short Summary

  • Investing in quality shingles from reputable manufacturers is essential for roof longevity, performance and home value.
  • Identify low-quality shingle brands to avoid costly repairs or replacements by evaluating material, construction, manufacturer reputation and warranty coverage.
  • Protect your roof with a reliable contractor and trusted brands while practicing regular maintenance to ensure durability over time.

The Importance of Choosing Quality Shingles

The Importance of Choosing Quality Shingles

Selecting the best roofing shingles is crucial for safeguarding your home and possessions from extreme weather conditions and other potential risks. When considering factors such as warranties, product offerings, and pricing, it’s essential to prioritize the quality of roofing materials.

By choosing the highest quality shingles from the top performance lines of leading shingle manufacturers, you can enjoy the benefits of new shingle technologies, such as algae-resistant roof shingles, Energy Star-certified reflective shingles, and improved self-sealing strips.

These features can help to reduce energy costs, extend the life of your roof, and protect your roof.

Roof Longevity

Roof longevity is the period of time a roof can remain intact prior to requiring repairs or replacements. High-quality shingles, such as dimensional or architectural shingles, can extend the roof’s lifespan, thereby reducing the necessity for frequent roof installations.

Dimensional shingles are laminated shingles that are manufactured as a double-layered, and occasionally triple-layered, product, providing more robust and premium protection compared to basic strip shingles. On the other hand, using low-quality asphalt shingle brands can result in frequent repairs or replacements, decreasing the roof’s longevity.

Luxury shingles are the most robust and premium dimensional shingles available, offering the best roofing shingles protection and aesthetic appeal for residential properties. Investing in luxury shingles from reputable manufacturers can ensure that your roof remains in excellent condition for many years to come, minimizing the chances of premature aging or damage to your roof.

Roof Performance

The importance of roof performance cannot be overstated; it is essential for safeguarding your home from the elements and ensuring its longevity. Low-grade roofing material can cause leaks, damage, and other roofing problems that can be expensive to fix. To minimize these issues, consider selecting the best asphalt shingles by reviewing the manufacturer’s reputation, choosing shingles with a good warranty, and opting for trusted brands.

Production quality has a significant impact on the performance of asphalt shingle roofs, as it decreases the likelihood of common problems. When selecting shingles, prioritizing the quality of the material used, such as polymer modified asphalt, the roof design, and the quality of installation will ensure a long-lasting, high-performing roof. Moreover, features such as IKO’s colorfast blue-green algae-resistant granules containing copper can make the roof less suitable for algae growth, thereby maintaining a clean and attractive roof.

Home Value and Insurance Premiums

High-quality shingles from a reputable manufacturer can provide discounts on homeowner’s insurance policy premiums, potentially up to 20%. This can be beneficial for homeowners in terms of property value and insurance premiums. For instance, Owens Corning offers a 50-year non-prorated warranty for their shingles, while Malarkey’s shingle lines are covered by a lifetime warranty with 100% coverage for multiple years followed by proration for the remainder of the term.

Investing in shingles with a Class 4 impact resistance rating can make residential property owners eligible for a decrease in their residential insurance premium. Homeowners can potentially save up to 20% on their homeowner’s insurance policy premiums by investing in a new roof with highly-rated performance shingles from a reputable shingle manufacturer.

Identifying Low-Quality Shingles

When assessing shingle brands, it’s crucial to consider factors such as the material and construction of the product, the reputation of the manufacturer, and the warranty coverage. Strip shingles, which were first manufactured in the 1920s, are the most basic type of asphalt shingles and may not provide the same level of durability and protection as more advanced shingle types, such as dimensional or architectural shingles.

By paying close attention to these factors, you can avoid low-quality shingles that may lead to costly repairs or replacements.

Material and Construction

Assessing shingle materials and construction methods is critical in order to evaluate the quality of the shingles and the durability of the roof. Inadequate materials and construction methods, such as low-grade asphalt and poor-quality adhesives, can result in accelerated aging, fracturing, and inadequate resistance to environmental conditions.

When selecting quality shingles, it is beneficial to review the manufacturer’s reputation, select shingles that come with a good warranty, and opt for trusted brands. Additionally, it is advisable to hire a reliable roofing contractor and conduct regular roof maintenance to ensure the integrity of your roof and shingles.

Manufacturer Reputation

Investigating manufacturers’ reputations within the roofing community is critical in ascertaining shingle quality. Some manufacturers, like IKO, are known to provide good quality shingles at a relatively lower price than other manufacturers. To research a manufacturer’s reputation, consider reading reviews from other customers, consulting roofing professionals, and researching online.

Investigating manufacturers’ reputations is necessary to make an educated choice when buying shingles. By choosing a manufacturer with a solid reputation, you can be more confident in the quality and performance of your roof shingles, ensuring a durable and long-lasting roof for your home.

Warranty Coverage

Warranty coverage can be utilized to evaluate shingle quality. When assessing shingle quality, it is important to consider:

  • The material used
  • Manufacturing process
  • Installation method
  • Climate
  • Roof design
  • Quality of installation
  • Maintenance

A limited warranty that does not extend to damage caused by weather or other external factors could be a red flag, indicating subpar shingle quality.

Opting for shingles with a comprehensive warranty from a reputable manufacturer can provide you with peace of mind and assurance in the quality of your roof. Be sure to read the warranty terms carefully and understand what is covered before making a purchase decision.

Brands to Avoid: The Worst Shingles Manufacturers of 2023

Brands to Avoid: The Worst Shingle Manufacturers of 2023

When selecting a shingle manufacturer, it is imperative to take into account aspects such as material quality, performance, and customer feedback. In 2023, Tamko and Malarkey are among the least preferred shingle brands, whereas CertainTeed, Owens Corning, and Atlas are considered the best shingle manufacturers.

By avoiding these worst shingle manufacturers and opting for more reputable options, you can ensure the longevity and performance of your roof. Here’s an overview of the issues associated with these brands:


Tamko is a well-known shingle manufacturer that has been in operation for several decades. However, it has faced criticism for the following reasons:

  1. Quality Control Issues: Numerous complaints have been reported regarding the quality of Tamko shingles. Customers have experienced problems such as premature cracking, curling, and granule loss. These issues suggest a lack of proper quality control during the manufacturing process.
  2. Limited Warranty Coverage: Although Tamko offers warranty coverage for its shingles, customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the company’s warranty service. Some claim that Tamko often denies warranty claims or makes the process difficult and time-consuming.
  3. Inconsistent Colors: Another common complaint about Tamko shingles is the inconsistency in color matching. This issue becomes apparent when customers try to replace damaged shingles or add new ones to an existing roof. The mismatched colors can negatively impact the overall appearance of the roof.


Malarkey is another shingle manufacturer that has received negative feedback from consumers. Here are some of the concerns associated with Malarkey shingles:

  1. Durability Issues: Customers have reported problems with the durability of Malarkey shingles. Issues like cracking, blistering, and premature aging have been mentioned. These problems can lead to leaks and other roof-related issues.
  2. Limited Availability: Malarkey shingles are not as widely available as some other brands, making it difficult for customers to find them in certain regions. Limited availability can be a drawback, especially if homeowners prefer Malarkey’s specific product offerings.
  3. Price: Malarkey shingles are often considered expensive compared to other brands offering similar quality. The higher price point may deter some customers who are looking for more affordable options without compromising on quality.

It’s important to note that opinions on shingle manufacturers can vary, and experiences may differ from one customer to another.

It’s always recommended to conduct thorough research, read customer reviews, and consult with roofing professionals before making a decision on which brand of shingles to choose for your specific needs.

Common Problems with Low-Quality Shingles

Low-quality shingles often suffer from:

  • Durability issues
  • Weather resistance problems
  • Premature cracking
  • Blistering
  • Curling
  • Granule loss

These issues can result in leaks, damage, and other roofing problems that can be expensive to fix and significantly reduce the lifespan of your roof.

By being aware of these common problems and taking steps to avoid low-quality shingles, you can protect your home and minimize potential damage.

Cracked Shingles

Cracked shingles can result from the utilization of inferior materials and a weakened base, as well as aging and exposure to extreme temperatures. Cracked shingles can lead to leaks and other harm to the roof, necessitating expensive repairs. To ensure the integrity of your roof shingles, select a reliable roofing contractor, utilize reliable shingle brands, and carry out regular roof maintenance.

Properly installed high-quality shingles can resist cracking and other damage caused by weather and natural wear and tear. By investing in quality materials and installation, you can prolong the life of your roof and avoid costly repairs associated with cracked shingles.

Premature Aging

Premature aging of low-quality shingles is often attributed to factors such as:

  • Shingle quality
  • Roof ventilation
  • Climatic conditions
  • Installation techniques

When shingles age prematurely, they can lose their protective qualities and become more susceptible to damage, leading to a shorter lifespan for the roof.

To prevent premature aging of your roof, follow these steps:

  1. Invest in high-quality shingles from reputable manufacturers.
  2. Ensure proper roof ventilation.
  3. Hire experienced roofing professionals for installation.
  4. Regularly maintain your roof to identify and address any issues before they lead to significant damage or costly repairs.

Poor Resistance to Weather Conditions

Low-quality shingles may not be constructed with materials that are robust enough to withstand extreme weather conditions, leading to poor resistance to weather. Inadequate installation can also contribute to shingle blow-offs caused by strong winds.

Inadequate resistance to weather conditions can result in damage from wind, rain, hail, and other weather-related factors, manifesting in cracked, curled, or blown-off shingles, leading to leaks and other damage to the roof. Protecting your roof from the negative effects of weather requires the use of high-quality shingles and proper installation techniques.

Ensure that your roofing contractor is experienced and knowledgeable, and invest in shingles from reputable manufacturers to provide the best possible protection for your home.

How to Protect Your Roof from Poor-Quality Shingles

How to Protect Your Roof from Poor-Quality Shingles

To ensure your roof is protected from low-grade shingles, select a reliable roofing contractor, go for established shingle brands, and carry out regular roof upkeep. By taking these measures, you can prolong the life of your roof, avoid costly repairs, and maintain the integrity of your home’s structure.

Choose a Reputable Roofing Contractor

Selecting reputable roofing contractors is beneficial due to their extensive experience and expertise, as well as access to high-quality materials at competitive prices. Reputable contractors may also provide insurance and warranty coverage and offer superior customer service. To identify a reputable roofing contractor, request references, assess reviews, and obtain quotes from various contractors. Additionally, ensure the contractor holds a valid license and is insured.

By choosing a reputable roofing contractor, you can ensure that your roof installation is done correctly, minimizing the risk of leaks or damage caused by improper installation. This investment in quality installation can save you money on repairs and maintenance in the long run.

Opt for Trusted Shingle Brands

Choosing trusted shingle brands offers several advantages, such as improved quality and durability, which can result in cost savings for homeowners over time. Trusted shingle brands are typically more reliable and have a good standing in the industry, providing homeowners with greater assurance. GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, and Tamko are all well-respected shingle brands to consider.

By opting for well-known and reputable shingle brands, you can be confident in the quality and performance of your roof shingles, ensuring a durable and long-lasting roof for your home. These trusted brands include:

  • GAF
  • Owens Corning
  • CertainTeed
  • Atlas

These brands may also offer better warranties and customer service, giving you additional peace of mind.

Regular Roof Maintenance

Regular roof maintenance is essential as it helps to avoid expensive repairs, prolongs the roof’s lifespan, and detects and rectifies minor issues before they become more serious. Inspecting the roof for any signs of damage, such as missing or cracked shingles, loose flashing, or other signs of wear and tear, as well as checking for any signs of water damage, such as water stains or mold growth, are recommended procedures for regular roof maintenance.

It is recommended to perform regular roof maintenance at least annually, preferably in the spring or fall. Additionally, it is advisable to inspect the roof following any major storms or weather events to identify and address any potential damage. By performing routine roof maintenance, you can preserve the integrity of your roof and protect your home from costly repairs or damage.


The quality of the shingles you choose for your roof plays a vital role in the longevity, performance, and overall protection of your home.

By selecting high-quality shingles from reputable manufacturers, hiring a reliable roofing contractor, and conducting regular roof maintenance, you can ensure the durability and longevity of your roof while avoiding costly repairs and issues associated with low-quality shingles.

Protect your home and your investment by making informed decisions when it comes to your roof.

Looking For Reliable And Efficient Roofing Repair Services?

Look no further than MPLS Roofing!

Whether you’re dealing with missing or damaged shingles, our team of skilled professionals is here to provide top-notch solutions. With years of experience in the industry, we specialize in restoring roofs to their optimal condition.

Don’t let roofing issues compromise the safety and integrity of your home—contact MPLS Roofing today and enjoy peace of mind knowing that your roof is in expert hands!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Class 3 and Class 4 shingles?

The difference between Class 3 and Class 4 shingles is that Class 4 has higher impact resistance, as it is designed to withstand a larger steel ball dropped from a greater height. Class 3 shingles can withstand steel balls that are 44 mm or 1.75 inches in diameter. Class 4 shingles can withstand steel balls that are 50.8 mm or 2 inches in diameter.

What happens when shingles are damaged?

When shingles are damaged, they can start to curl, crack, blister, and lose their granules. In addition, roofing contractors may find pieces of roofing shingles scattered along the roof’s surface and gutters.

Without repair or replacement, shingle damage will continue to cause problems such as leakage and moisture damage, resulting in costly repairs for the homeowner.

What are the benefits of choosing high-quality shingles?

Choosing high-quality shingles offers superior protection against extreme weather conditions, extends roof lifespans, and can result in cost savings over the long term.

Investing in quality shingles now can help you avoid costly repairs and replacements in the future. Quality shingles are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, such as high winds, hail, and heavy rain. They also provide superior insulation, helping them to provide superior insulation.

What factors should I consider when selecting shingles?

When selecting shingles, it’s important to take into account the material and construction, the reputation of the manufacturer, as well as any warranty coverage they provide. Make sure you do your research to make an informed choice.